Bidvertiser Review (Sponsored)

This is a sponsored review of the bidvertiser advertising program. It contains affiliate links to the bidvertiser program.

I signed up with bidvertiser after reading Andy Beard’s Bidvertiser Review I even blogged on it myself too.

You can sign up as an Advertiser, a Publisher or Both. They also have a referal program where you can earn up to $50 for new publisher sign ups and $25 for new advertiser signup, both of which are conditional upon performance.

Advertising with Bidvertiser

I must confess I haven’t yet used the advertiser product, so can’t really comment on its effectiveness. I’m sure people will be able to find out info on this with a quick Google.

Publishing and Bidvertiser

I wasn’t too impressed with the backend system at bidvertiser. I briefly touched on those here . To elaborate further, my biggest issue was with what for me is just too clunky a system.

As a blogger I just want a quick and easy way of getting ads on my sites and getting paid. When you log in to the publisher backend you are auto opted in to a long list of advertisers. I didn’t enjoy having to go through 240 + advertisers disapproving sites I didn’t really feel were relevant. It was a royal PITA. I think a better system would give me an option to enable myself to opt out of all advertisers and then selectively choose which ones I wanted to allow. Sure, some people might not care what ads they show, probably because they have a broader reach or appeal yet for a tech blog like this I see little value for myself, my readers or potential advertisers in showing links to sites like Russian Brides 4 Marriage’ and ‘Casino’ and ‘Rehab, Drug and Alcohol’ . To make matters worse, once having been through what can only be described as the rigmarole of a disapproval process. I then found I had to go back and constantly tweak and add and disapprove as new advertisers came on board.

I really don’t have time to mess around like that,so for that reason and that reason alone I decided to remove the ad code.

Would I reconsider? Sure, yes of course I would, but before I did they’d have to improve upon how it currently works. I would like to see.

  • Catergorised ad channels – would allow me to more specific about the kinds of ad channels I wanted to show. If I run a tech site then I want tech related ads. If I run a drug rehab site then again the same kind of thing applies. I don’t see the point in showing ads to Russian Brides for Marriage websites as in 99.9% of cases very few people who read a tech blog are really that interested in such things. I want to give them ads that are in the very least somewhat related in some way.
  • Minimum bid rate options – What is the point in me showing ads from a network that are going to pay me such a base minimum. Niche blogs target all manner of sectors and themes. Different markets have different levels of participation and therefore profitability. A blog that deals with finance or gambling as a subject matter would ideally wish to display adverts of related content. Ads in this sector tend tomore expensive than those of other sectors due in the main to the high returns that can be made from serious program participants. A casino affiliate can earn great commisions, as can casino operators too, simply due to the high level of spend by the average new player. Why would any blogger blogging on the topic of gambling want to show a low bid 0.05c ad to a site talking about unrelated stuff, when a relevant ad could perform so much better. By having a minimum bid option, a site that decided on a benchmark level, could work from that base and if so wished exclude further as appropriate.
  • Opt in to advertiser options – I alluded to this above and understand that as a program bidvertiser wants to get their advertisers ads out there in the space, but jees, do please also appreciate that not all of your publishers are that carefree with who they link to or show even. If at least an option existed to automagically opt out of all, then this would be very much the welcome time saver. Publishers could then look at the list and selectively include whomever they saw fit. I’d like to be able to also have a a checkbox that prevented new advertisers from appearing as well as maybe an email alert otion if ‘ads opted in to ‘ fell below a certain threshold.Update:

    My bad. I have since noticed that there is an option to manually approve each new ad, and filter out sites you may not wish to publish; such as your competitors. I hadn’t noticed this though as it wasn’t immediately apparent.

    They also allow you to contact them and request inclusion in different categories. This domain was assigned to which to me is pretty restrictive Computer & Internet –> Internet Services –> Search Engines I dont get why if this is my classification I had ads for all manner of unrelated areas but hey…

Bidvertiser Referal Program

I think that the referal program has the potential to be a very good thing but feel that it could be improved somewhat. They offer up to $25 for advertiser sign ups and up to $50 for new publisher sign ups.

Whilst the lure of $25 and $50 per new sign up is on the face of things attractive, when you look at it further you do realise that once these thresholds are met, your bucks stop there.

It would be both cool and I’m sure affordable if there was some additional ongoing passive stream. Maybe some tiered bonuses relative to either advertiser spend or publisher income generation.

If bidvertiser are seriously looking to grow their publisher base then IMO they could do far worse then step up to the plate and offer its partners serious ongoing incentives.

Conclusion

On the whole I think bidvertiser has a lot of potential.

With a sufficient publisher and advertiser base it could obviously do very well indeed.

The success of Google, YPN, Adbrite and Kontera to name but a few are a living testament to this. I can’t vouch for the effectiveness of their ads from either an advertiser or publisher perspective. In many ways they look very similar to most of the other players in the marketplace and could certainly do with some additional formatting options. I think there are as witnessed by some of the advertisers who are using them, some excellent opportunities for the arbitragers of this world to come in to programs like this and exploit some of the low cost offerings that are to be had there.

Its obvious to conclude that a successful program of this type has to live up to the aims and expectations of all its constituents and users, with a little bit of work Bidvertiser IMO, could well do this.

update :

Rob Watts
Kickstart your business today - Get an SEO Consultation or just talk to Rob about your online aspirations. With over 20 years experience in building traffic he's pretty much encountered most markets and scenarios
Posted on: 5th June 2007, by : Rob Watts

6 thoughts on “Bidvertiser Review (Sponsored)

  1. Excellent paid for review. Not for the product, I couldn’t care less. But for the advice you gave them, they definately got their monies worth for a lot of free consultancy.

    I read too many paid reviews that are embarrased to say bad things about the product, Rob had no problem here. So when Rob raves about something, you know he actually means it.

    In my opinion your review price is way too low, and after this review your credibility in the eyes of your readers should rocket.

    Rob, I am interested to know your criteria for picking a review.

  2. Hey Lyndon, thanks for the kind words dude.

    To be honest I haven’t really looked too much into the review post thing. I only recently put up a badge or two here and there.

    I’m not one for wasting my time talking about stuff that I’m not really interested in so, I guess you wont really find me taking on board, “8 quid postive review required we just want a link” type gigs.

    So yeah, if I do a review on something then at worst Ive got a genuine interest in what it is they do or who they are and what they can bring to my little world.

    I won’t do a review that demands a positive spin because thats kinda crappy and valueless really. It’s almost akin to lying about a thing, just because some mother paid you to write it. I just aint gonna do it.

  3. Looks like I have some competition on the high quality review front, great stuff 🙂

    I am giving them a full month on the adverts that are running, though for some reason the higher paid ads which are meant to run don’t seem to show up – and it doesn’t seem to be due to Geo-Location.

    I did delete a load of adverts on the lower end. I know what the typical payout for a click is for blogging and internet marketing blogs through Adsense, and it the clicks I have achieved with Bidvertiser seem lower.

    Sure I could improve positioning for more clicks, but that would be true of any adverts.

  4. Cheers Andy, if a jobs worth doing you might as well try and do it properley eh 😀

    You’ve given me some great examples to aim at, so kudos there bloke.

    They only asked for like 50 words, I gave them 800 odd so I can’t be criticised for effort. 😉

    It really seems like they paid a lot more attention to the advertiser backend than the publisher side of things, but I guess that in some respects thats inevitable in the early days. These things are about profit and making money after all.

    I saw the same on those high paying ads too. I think maybe that the upper tier higher spend advertisers might be editorially steered towards certain properties, dependant upon ad budgets and what not. Maybe those bidvertiser peeps will stop on by and clear a few things up.

  5. Hi
    Just thought I would ask…
    Im using Bidvertizer, and most of the time My site shows the standard “Get $20 Free Advertisement”. I have complained many times but no luck… It seems as though Bidvertizer is stealing my impressions and thus my ad space…

    Firstly it is extremely worrying that an ad network would continually show there own ads on a site… it seems dishonest.

    Has anyone else experianced this.?

  6. Not me personally, Jeremy no.

    I no longer use it to be honest, and when I did it was for a very short time.

    I think it had the making of a good program but (IMO) just didn’t get enough advertisers or publishers on board so up to now at least, has kind of failed in getting up there with the big boys. It certainly has it’s uses though, I just wouldn’t use it for publishing purposes, simply because pound for pound the others that I use give me bigger earning opportunities and outcomes.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

css.php
%d bloggers like this: